Home Forums Free SciFi Gaming Projects Pioneer The case against Earth

Viewing 15 posts - 1 through 15 (of 33 total)



Humble Book Bundle ends on 9/11/2019


  • Author
    Posts
  • #57840
    AvatarCavefish
    Participant

    We all know Sol is a fine joint. But Earth is problematic. It is too well known. It has too many cities. It can be never replicated believably in the game. It would require custom high-resolution textures and that will never fit in with the procedural generatedness of the rest of the galaxy.

    Frontier solved this problem by making Earth an unrecognizable mudball while the terraformed Mars was the new place to be. I think we should do something similar. I say we blow it up.

    Just put a huge asteroid field where Earth should be. Blame it on an unfortunate accident of the past. A collision with a stray asteroid. Intergalactic road construction. LHC. Just get rid of it.

    1NUY.jpg




    Humble Book Bundle ends on 9/11/2019


    #72872
    Avatartomm
    Participant

    Very tempting. Also, I think the future is more exciting if we’ve destroyed earth somehow. I was considering raising the sea level by 80 meters to indicate the almost inevitable results of climate change :J

    The earth height map is fairly low resolution, which produces silly looking curvy coastlines that other (fractal) planets don’t have. This could be hidden slightly by adding a fractal on top (which I have done, and results in the ugly blobs all over earth’s terrain). Hm.

    How about, shortly after hyperspace is invented the earth is destroyed by a black hole created by a hyperdrive experiment too close to the planet surface? Then you can visit earth and you’ll see a big black thing with lots of gravity that kills you.

    Cavefish wrote:
    We all know Sol is a fine joint. But Earth is problematic. It is too well known. It has too many cities. It can be never replicated believably in the game. It would require custom high-resolution textures and that will never fit in with the procedural generatedness of the rest of the galaxy.

    Frontier solved this problem by making Earth an unrecognizable mudball while the terraformed Mars was the new place to be. I think we should do something similar. I say we blow it up.

    Just put a huge asteroid field where Earth should be. Blame it on an unfortunate accident of the past. A collision with a stray asteroid. Intergalactic road construction. LHC. Just get rid of it.

    1NUY.jpg

    #72873
    GeraldineGeraldine
    Participant

    Maybe Tomm, you could also just re-texture the Earth to make it a polluted mess. More thoughts, perhaps have a mission to restore it to it’s former glory by way of some G.E.C.K torpedo?

    #72874
    Avatars2odan
    Participant

    Poor old Earth, what did she ever do to you?

    Tomm you should use a better heightmap. I have heightmaps from Orbiter for Earth, moon and mars all about 7 times detail what you currently have for earth. While it still won’t have the detail of the fractally generated planets it would look a heck of a lot better than it is now.

    What about textures? There are lots of extremely high quality textures for earth (obviously 🙂 ).

    If you really feel you have to destroy our home, then I’d go with the flooding.

    #72875
    AvatarPotsmoke66
    Participant

    low me, i can’t say that this will hinder me to play pioneer

    of course it could have more cities or more exactly textured surface, whatever!

    i still like to play pioneer (and frontier of course) because of many other aspects then exactly a extreme realism of mother earth (btw, the brown blob is from ffe, in frontier it was the topaz it is still fortunately).

    in my actual career of pioneer, i visited earth only once, but i’ts no good place to run to for a trader 😆

    a bit low i must say, can’t understand what is so special about sol?

    “a rather avarage type G star with some indigenous lifeforms on the third planet, which still struggle for control, not recognizing that they will loose everything this way” i would say as a alien.

    most time you gamble around in open space, guess i won’t see many surfaces in a active played game, it’s of course a part of the whole thing, but not more important as other aspects.

    cities in a game like pioneer could never reach a full realism it would over exceed everything still.

    but we will do our best, to make it as reasonable as possible.

    something i would wish for planets and/or cities is still a possibility to have various city scapes, i still believe two simple factors can rule that, surface temperature and atmosphere type (most important aspect and will give the chance to have at least two general types of architecture).

    talking about a catastrophe, i would choose a war, between humans of course, no aliens, still we are the ones that work most intensive on the goal to turn the topaz into a brown blob. 😉

    flooding, hm, i’m not shure if this will ever happen…

    …i guess we are faster.

    something i always liked about frontier and it might sound strange for guests, frontier sharpens the feelings for our home and how precious it is, of course a wanted aspect of mr.braben, i’m shure.

    on the other hand, if i look at who plays the game at all, everybody seems to tend belong to a class of people that allready care about that.

    because if i look at the dislikers, i can see a very different kind of our society, like my son, more practical thinking and stating that everybody will fight for himself and his fortune. what does he liked to play?

    FPS

    i guess that tells a lot, i won’t judge here, but it’s interesting, no?

    so there are dreamers like we are and stoic ones like he is…

    sorry, i slipped off topic again (shut your mouth and make some new models, that’s the best you can do! 😈 )

    #72876
    AvatarPotsmoke66
    Participant

    s20dan,

    how do you get to the vid of my favorite waste of time? 😆

    #72877
    Avatars2odan
    Participant

    Sorry I don’t understand, maybe im a little slow today 🙂

    What vid we talking about?

    Edit// This? startrek%20cod4.gif

    #72878
    MarcelMarcel
    Participant

    How about a procedural algorithm for Earth that would turn the whole planet into one gigantic city? Make the whole thing out of cubes, etc. like Trantor in the Foundation trilogy or the capital planet in Star Wars whose name I forget at the moment?

    #72879
    AvatarHawkerT
    Participant

    The case FOR Earth!!!

    I agree with s20dan and Marcel completely on this one.

    Definitely keep Gaia alive and preferably also looking her best.

    Coming ‘home’ from the far reaches of the universe has a special attraction to me and always feels good but put’s the fragility of our world into context at the same time. Why should we as game players be sad when coming ‘home’ in Pioneer? I don’t play games to become sad or depressed! That is so easily done in real life and to be honest a daily philosophical struggle to overcome.

    Have a little faith brothers and sisters, if not in your fellow man then at least in Gaia! There are many out there just like you and you love Gaia right? Not all of mankind is stinking and rotten to the core and since we all posses the duality of good and evil most can be turned to the bright side of the force.

    I say let Gaia shine in Pioneer! I don’t care if she is not absolutely perfect in Pioneer, just show her correctly enough to overcome the suspension of disbelief and the imagination will do the rest. I mean come’on you have all played the original Elite with vector graphics and all.

    A giant city covering the globe is also fine with me, and If you must have man kill himself by whatever means with most of the surface in the process then so be it, but then I would go with the flooded world. You could even go against the fancy currents of gloom and doom and put a positive spin on the whole flooding thing making it an attempt to leave the Earth alone to recuperate from her man inflicted scars.

    Frans

    #72880
    Avatars2odan
    Participant
    Quote:
    You could even go against the fancy currents of gloom and doom and put a positive spin on the whole flooding thing making it an attempt to leave the Earth alone to recuperate from her man inflicted scars.

    Yes I suppose the flooding would have to be deliberate in some way. As surely if man can terraform worlds and colonise interstellar space, he knows a few tricks to combat a natural flood.

    Quote:
    Make the whole thing out of cubes, etc. like Trantor in the Foundation trilogy or the capital planet in Star Wars whose name I forget at the moment?

    Anything that makes its way into the game from the Foundation Trilogy is a bloody good thing in my book.

    I loved those extra bits of info in FFE about Hari Seldon and the Trantor like world that was a few hundred LYs west of Earth. Of course the Real Trantor was 1000s of LYs away right on the Galactic rim I think.

    EDIT// its not Trantor I’m thinking of, what was the name of the High tech world set up by Hari Seldon on the edge of the galaxy?

    The name to the StarWars city is Coruscant. All copied from Trantor 🙂

    #72881
    AvatarTonySpike
    Participant

    perhaps coruscant would be a logical choice but mabe were looking at this from a biased perspective being actualy from earth means that its the place we make special

    its like when i draw a map of europe

    i make england the best because i know it the best cos its my home

    whereas the rest of europe i make rough guesses and poland ends up roughly round in shape italy ends up nothing more than a boot and germany ends up looking nothing like it should

    im not a cartographer so you get my point

    maybe the same is true with stellar cartography

    earth needs to not be any better than any other dustball in the universe its only special to humans im sure imps think topaz is tha bomb in the same way

    and come on if it was so great why did we ever leave it in the first place

    map it as accuratly as possible but i dont care about how great it is just get it in their

    #72882
    AvatarPotsmoke66
    Participant

    hawkerT, thumbs up!

    Quote:
    You could even go against the fancy currents of gloom and doom and put a positive spin on the whole flooding thing making it an attempt to leave the Earth alone to recuperate from her man inflicted scars.

    good idea!

    it sounds like i heard that somewhere before… 😎

    should i put engine parts to the archology and make a ship out of it? a huge carrier with a giant dome. a station using the domes is allready planned, could be also a giant ring type station.

    also the small buildings are to imagine as capsules or something like that, they have allready a small biosphere built in.

    who knows, maybe mankind slips underground and only a few surface buildings are left to see on the surface.

    #72883
    AvatarBugbear
    Participant
    potsmoke66 wrote:

    who knows, maybe mankind slips underground and only a few surface buildings are left to see on the surface.

    This sounds like the simplest solution, combined with a mass exodus of earth’s population.

    Put me in the camp of the “Save the Earth Foundation”.

    I’d rather not see my home planet trashed or covered in metal.

    Can trees be procedurally generated?

    #72884
    AvatarUncleBob
    Participant

    Whatever you do, please don’t destroy her by A BLACK HOLE! It’s the most silly means of destroying a planet I know about.

    #72885
    Avatars2odan
    Participant
    Quote:
    Can trees be procedurally generated?

    That would be great. I’m pretty sure that in Infinity the trees are all placed procedurally but perhaps they are created procedurally too like in Ad-Astra 🙂 In which literally everything is procedurally created, even the ships.

    Quote:
    Whatever you do, please don’t destroy her by A BLACK HOLE! It’s the most silly means of destroying a planet I know about.

    Even xenophobic aliens would be a better answer than a black-hole 🙂

    Cern is coming to get you!!!

Viewing 15 posts - 1 through 15 (of 33 total)
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.