Alien Life Deemed impossible.

Discuss anything related to outer space, discoveries, missions and theories of the universe our little blue planet is a part of.
XenonS
Private
Posts: 398
Joined: Wed Dec 14, 2016 1:09 am

RE: Alien Life Deemed impossible.

Post by XenonS »

Oh, just one thing about the so-called WOW signal:It has often be argued that the signal has never repeated, which is true, but totally irrelevant and this argument is also fallacious.If we ever receive a type-2 signal it would already be by the means of incredible fortune involved. It's then important to record and document it well so that further analisis can take place. Has this been done with the WOW and has it been analized? The statements from SETI or the involved astronomers are all not crystal clear about this, so people on the street didn't get a satisfying answer IMO. Go on the Seti home page and type in wow in the search, you will find plain nothing. Google it on the net and you will find a lot of UFO stuff, but nothing interesting and to-the-point.It's totally stupid to consider that the same type-2 signal would ever come to us twice (a type-1 signal is different obviously!), so who has put this naive idea in the world, I don't know, but he must have been drunken...The shorter a signal is, the most probable it's a type-2, especially if it doesn't repeat. So a signal not repeating has of course information value, but to say "it must repeat in order for us to be considered" that's trash. References:For example, the very first google result ("wow signal analyzed") tells a lot but says nothing, also it adheres to the fallacy explained above: http://news.discovery.com/space/alien-life-exoplanets/the-wow-signal-130524.htm[/url] Or take this one:http://www.setileague.org/articles/calibwow.htm[/url] interesting, but the author doesn't give any meaningful conclusion in simple words, so it's rather worthless (at least for our purpose). This one is hilarious:Don't read all this and waste your time, instead just scroll down to the "Conclusion". Should I say more?http://www.bigear.org/Wow30th/wow30th.htm[/url] The Wikipedia article:https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wow!_signal[/url] contains interesting data about the signal but no conclusion to what it means in simple words. Someone seeking to find wether this signal is useful or even evidence for ET won't find a yes or no answer. By carefully going through the article, the answer is no (still assuming it's referenced and complete), but few people will have the patience and a lot of folks would rather advance 'spectacular' theories in the absence of such answer, biasing the overall value and creating a myth. All such articles and their waterfall of words aren't to give any explanations to people who aren't familiar with the scientific work, that is the majority of people. XenonS
Gunbladelad
Private
Posts: 133
Joined: Mon Jan 23, 2017 1:57 am

RE: Alien Life Deemed impossible.

Post by Gunbladelad »

Just pray it's not like this one...
XenonS
Private
Posts: 398
Joined: Wed Dec 14, 2016 1:09 am

RE: Alien Life Deemed impossible.

Post by XenonS »

I like your postscrypt (Where logic...) :cool: XS
XenonS
Private
Posts: 398
Joined: Wed Dec 14, 2016 1:09 am

RE: Alien Life Deemed impossible.

Post by XenonS »

The 'money' value of signals: Up to now, I haven't had any kind words about Mr. Yuri Milkin's project and his generous sponsoring. Maybe time has come to change this.Because the odds may be in Mr. Milkin's favor. My pessimistic calculation says: 1 chance out of 500 within 200 years to meet Alien. That's not too bad afterall. It means that if you bet 100 millions on it and expect a money return of 50 Billions, then you are alright to bet. In this case Mr. Milkin should marry soon and leave the profits to his children so they can build an Empire, because waiting for other 100 years (most likely waiting time) would not be enough to realize his personal profits. And still there is such a thing llike IRS or other taxes... It kinda remembers me of Ridley Scott's movie Prometheus, a pre-sequel of the Alien Series:Rich man wants to live longer - rich man sponsors spacecraft - rich man hides in the spacecraft - rich man meets Alien - Alien gets angry - end of the story. Humm...This story is so mundane, it is quite realistic. XenonS
Post Reply

Return to “Outer Space and Astronomy”