Good news bad news, great that they are making a series of the books, bad news is that it's apple TV.
Foundation
RE: Foundation
Posted by: @pinback
bad news is that it's apple TV.
Indeed!
bad news is that it's apple TV.
Indeed!
RE: Foundation
I see Lee Pace is in this, he is a good actor
Yeah definitely the bad news is its on Apple TV
this looks really good though here is hoping it comes to other platforms eventually.
Yeah definitely the bad news is its on Apple TV
this looks really good though here is hoping it comes to other platforms eventually.-
Gaius Konstantine
- Private
- Posts: 215
- Joined: Mon Feb 03, 2020 8:06 am
RE: Foundation
This trilogy was one of the first works of sci-fi I ever read, it not only introduced me to Mr. Asimov but a passion for space. Hope they do this justice.
RE: Foundation
Who that older guy in the trailer I know his face from something but can't place him.
RE: Foundation
Posted by: @pinback
Who that older guy in the trailer
Jared Harris?
Who that older guy in the trailer
Jared Harris?
RE: Foundation
WOW...Foundation
If they are really serious about doing this epic story justice, it will need a whole bunch of movies to cover the 10,000 years of the original story. The true start of Foundation begins in the book Caves Of Steel as one of the main characters first appears in it. If done right, it needs to be treated on the same level as Lord Of the Rings and the Star Wars Saga, plus its bigger than both of them combined.
Apple could spend longer than George Lucas took making this saga. If this is just a single movie however, I will be greatly disappointed.
If they are really serious about doing this epic story justice, it will need a whole bunch of movies to cover the 10,000 years of the original story. The true start of Foundation begins in the book Caves Of Steel as one of the main characters first appears in it. If done right, it needs to be treated on the same level as Lord Of the Rings and the Star Wars Saga, plus its bigger than both of them combined.
Apple could spend longer than George Lucas took making this saga. If this is just a single movie however, I will be greatly disappointed.
RE: Foundation
Jared Harris that's him, he was in the Expanse but I remember him better playing Moriarty in the last Sherlock Holmes film.
It going to be a Tv series Geraldine, so if it's successful their should be a number of series, don't recall how many books their are but I wonder if it's going to be one series per book or are they going to flesh it out a bit.
It going to be a Tv series Geraldine, so if it's successful their should be a number of series, don't recall how many books their are but I wonder if it's going to be one series per book or are they going to flesh it out a bit.
RE: Foundation
@pinback
This being a TV series is giving me worries about the scope they are aiming for. The Foundation series is massive. If this is the route they are looking at then it will need to be done in seasons. The closest thing done like this I can think of was the Babylon 5 story arc. Even then, this was tiny compared to Foundation. There isn't any comparable sci-fi story that covers so much time, so many events. Issac Asimov made this his life's work so I hope they pay it the respect it deserves.
This being a TV series is giving me worries about the scope they are aiming for. The Foundation series is massive. If this is the route they are looking at then it will need to be done in seasons. The closest thing done like this I can think of was the Babylon 5 story arc. Even then, this was tiny compared to Foundation. There isn't any comparable sci-fi story that covers so much time, so many events. Issac Asimov made this his life's work so I hope they pay it the respect it deserves.
RE: Foundation
Posted by: @geraldine
@pinback
This being a TV series is giving me worries about the scope they are aiming for. The Foundation series is massive. If this is the route they are looking at then it will need to be done in seasons. The closest thing done like this I can think of was the Babylon 5 story arc. Even then, this was tiny compared to Foundation. There isn't any comparable sci-fi story that covers so much time, so many events. Issac Asimov made this his life's work so I hope they pay it the respect it deserves.
Good point that given that a lot of these digital tv series seem to be only 13 episodes long instead of the normal 26.
@pinback
This being a TV series is giving me worries about the scope they are aiming for. The Foundation series is massive. If this is the route they are looking at then it will need to be done in seasons. The closest thing done like this I can think of was the Babylon 5 story arc. Even then, this was tiny compared to Foundation. There isn't any comparable sci-fi story that covers so much time, so many events. Issac Asimov made this his life's work so I hope they pay it the respect it deserves.
Good point that given that a lot of these digital tv series seem to be only 13 episodes long instead of the normal 26.
RE: Foundation
@pinback
A single season of 13 episodes would never be enough to do justice to the intricate storylines Asimov put into his books. Those storylines are what made the series great with so much going on, not only in the foreground, but the background too. Done properly, it would make Game Of Thrones look like a tired re-run of some hapless old soap opera. Just a single character; Eto Demerzel, a.k.a, R. Daneel Olivaw, could have a single season just about him....or rather it. Olivaw is the single thread weaving it's way all through those 10,000 years of human history doing his Machiavelli bit and that's just a single example.
My one hope is the Asimov estate will be all over this. I don't want to see a repeat of what Hollywood did to I Robot. That was a travesty to the book. Great action movie yes, but it had very little in common with the vision of Asimov wanted to portray of Robotics being introduced into human societies.
Sorry to go on so much Pinback but I just am totally sick of these glib movies Hollywood churns out these days. They need to do better and audiences today need better movies that stick closer to the author's original intent. Goodness knows all of us could do with an in depth look at a possible future society we might yet become in these trying times we now live in, to give us hope if nothing else.......
I'll get off my soapbox now.
[attach]38[/attach]
RE: Foundation
I was looking at Waterstones site yesterday, thinking I might buy the original trilogy again. Can't say I like that particular edition's (which I presume is the latest/current one) cover art though - not a patch on Foss' from the '70s.
The TV series will no doubt drive book sales, and Asimov's estate will cash in. But that cover art ain't got no soul!
The TV series will no doubt drive book sales, and Asimov's estate will cash in. But that cover art ain't got no soul!
RE: Foundation
I agree, the Foss covers are the best.
RE: Foundation
Posted by: @geraldine
I agree, the Foss covers are the best.
Those are the covers which used to grace my bookcase - 'til they fell apart! For reference:
I agree, the Foss covers are the best.
Those are the covers which used to grace my bookcase - 'til they fell apart! For reference:
RE: Foundation
Posted by: @geraldine
@pinback
A single season of 13 episodes would never be enough to do justice to the intricate storylines Asimov put into his books. Those storylines are what made the series great with so much going on, not only in the foreground, but the background too. Done properly, it would make Game Of Thrones look like a tired re-run of some hapless old soap opera. Just a single character; Eto Demerzel, a.k.a, R. Daneel Olivaw, could have a single season just about him....or rather it. Olivaw is the single thread weaving it's way all through those 10,000 years of human history doing his Machiavelli bit and that's just a single example.
My one hope is the Asimov estate will be all over this. I don't want to see a repeat of what Hollywood did to I Robot. That was a travesty to the book. Great action movie yes, but it had very little in common with the vision of Asimov wanted to portray of Robotics being introduced into human societies.
Sorry to go on so much Pinback but I just am totally sick of these glib movies Hollywood churns out these days. They need to do better and audiences today need better movies that stick closer to the author's original intent. Goodness knows all of us could do with an in depth look at a possible future society we might yet become in these trying times we now live in, to give us hope if nothing else.......
I'll get off my soapbox now.
[attach]38[/attach]
No worriers, Hollywood seems to have gone down a rabbit hole of endless sequels and meaningless remakes and underpants wearing super hero's.
Never realised that the three books made one picture.
@pinback
A single season of 13 episodes would never be enough to do justice to the intricate storylines Asimov put into his books. Those storylines are what made the series great with so much going on, not only in the foreground, but the background too. Done properly, it would make Game Of Thrones look like a tired re-run of some hapless old soap opera. Just a single character; Eto Demerzel, a.k.a, R. Daneel Olivaw, could have a single season just about him....or rather it. Olivaw is the single thread weaving it's way all through those 10,000 years of human history doing his Machiavelli bit and that's just a single example.
My one hope is the Asimov estate will be all over this. I don't want to see a repeat of what Hollywood did to I Robot. That was a travesty to the book. Great action movie yes, but it had very little in common with the vision of Asimov wanted to portray of Robotics being introduced into human societies.
Sorry to go on so much Pinback but I just am totally sick of these glib movies Hollywood churns out these days. They need to do better and audiences today need better movies that stick closer to the author's original intent. Goodness knows all of us could do with an in depth look at a possible future society we might yet become in these trying times we now live in, to give us hope if nothing else.......
I'll get off my soapbox now.
[attach]38[/attach]
No worriers, Hollywood seems to have gone down a rabbit hole of endless sequels and meaningless remakes and underpants wearing super hero's.
Never realised that the three books made one picture.
RE: Foundation
Yes, a practice that has been done a few times..
[attach]39[/attach]
[attach]39[/attach]
RE: Foundation
Oooh, look what I turned up part 1 of 8
RE: Foundation
Posted by: @pinback
Never realised that the three books made one picture.
Yeah, it makes a great poster. Posted by: @geraldine
Oooh, look what I turned up part 1 of 8
Yeah, I saw that yesterday too.
Never realised that the three books made one picture.
Yeah, it makes a great poster. Posted by: @geraldine
Oooh, look what I turned up part 1 of 8
Yeah, I saw that yesterday too.
RE: Foundation
Posted by: @geraldine
Oooh, look what I turned up part 1 of 8
Nice going to have a listen to that as it must be about thirty years since I read the books.
Oooh, look what I turned up part 1 of 8
Nice going to have a listen to that as it must be about thirty years since I read the books.
RE: Foundation
Had a listen to all 8 parts of the show and it was as my memory remembered as in a series of short stories. was that just the first book or is this an abridge adaption of all three books?.